When the 115th Congress adjourned, however, bills introduced but not enacted expired.

The The Texas Legislature ratified the Equal Rights Amendment during a special session on March 30, 1972. two states have recently ratified the ERA. Joint Resolution of March 22, 1972, 86 STAT 1523, Proposing an Amendment to the Constitution of the United States Relative to Equal Rights for Men and Women, 3/22/1972.

First, ERA advocates want to ignore the district courts decision because the Supreme Court vacated it without offering a substantive decision of its own. As laid out in Article 17 of the Texas Constitution, in order for a proposed constitutional amendment to be placed on the ballot, the Texas State Legislature must propose the amendment in a joint resolution of both the Texas State Senate and the Texas House of Representatives. Advocates ignore this difference by focusing instead on a supposed distinction between a textual time limitREF that appears in the proposed amendments text and time limits in a proposing clauseREF that appear in the joint resolutions text.

The issue is whether the 1972 ERA remains pending before the states. https://www.tshaonline.org, https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/texas-equal-rights-amendment. All 56 joint resolutions for proposing the ERA that include a ratification deadline place it in the proposing clause. This amendment is self-operative."! First, ERA advocates fail to distinguish between constitutional amendments, like the Madison Amendment, proposed without a ratification deadline and those, like the 1972 ERA, proposed with such a deadline. ERA advocates also assert that Congress has authority to amend or change a ratification deadline that appears in the proposing clause. WebThere are two paths available for the Equal Rights Amendment to be ratified to the U.S. Constitution. This suggestion was unusual in Dillon because the 18th Amendment, at issue in that case, had a seven-year ratification deadline.REF The issue in Dillon was whether Congress had authority to include any ratification deadline, not whether the time between proposal and ratification met any particular standard. Even National Public Radio acknowledges that the 1972 ERA fell short and expired in 1982.REF The widely used resource Lexis-Nexis includes the 1972 ERA on a list of failed amendments, noting that it never received ratification by the necessary three-fourths of the states.REF. On February 8, 2016, the American Bar Associations House of Delegates adopted Resolution 10B, submitted by the New Jersey State Bar, generally supporting ratification of the ERA. Public policy. The joint resolution proposing the 21st Amendment, which would repeal the 18th, opens this way: Resolvedthat the following article is hereby proposed as an amendment to the Constitution of the United States, which shall be validwhen ratified by conventions in three-fourths of the several States..

The federal ERA passed the house by a vote of 133 to 9 and passed the senate by a unanimous voice-vote.22 Amendment and, because three-fourths of the state legislatures did not ratify before the deadline that Congress imposed, the Equal Rights Amendment has failed of adop-tion and is no longer pending before the States. After years of attempts to get it passed, on March 22, 1972, the Senate voted by84 to eight to send the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) to the states forratification. The seven-year ratification deadline appeared in the text of the amendment itself and, when that deadline passed with only 16 ratifying states, the amendment expired.

For these reasons, the U.S. Department of Justices Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) concluded that Dillons discussionwas merely a dictum.REF, While the Courts comment in Dillon about ratification being sufficiently contemporaneous is irrelevant because, as dictum, it is not legal binding precedent, Colemans treatment of this issue is irrelevant for a different reason. In any case, not all alterations have been accepted. The Equal Rights Amendment followed the prescribed process and was passed by both chambers of Congress.

Webochsner obgyn residents // did texas ratify the equal rights amendment of 1972? The Equal Rights Amendment was a proposed 27th Amendment to the United States

The Equal Rights Amendment, in its most recently proposed form, reads, Equality of rights under the law shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or any State on account of sex., READ MORE: How Phyllis Schlafly Derailed the Equal Rights Amendment. Then one in September, one in November, one in January, followed by four in February, and two more prior to the anniversary. Texas added an equal rights amendment to its own constitutionin November of 1972. Though it was first drafted 100 years ago, the ERAa proposed amendment that would enshrine gender equality in the U.S. Constitution and legally prohibit discrimination on the basis of sexhas yet to be added to our countrys founding document.. Congress voted in WebOn March 22, 1972, a lopsided bipartisan majority approved the amendment: 84 senators voted aye; eight, including Ervin, voted nay. You can also find more information about Frances Tarlton Sissy Farenthold, a key figure in passing the Texas ERA, via this project from the University of Texas School of Law and the Dolph Briscoe Center. Governor Ben Ramsey argued that women in his region preferred the protection of existing Texas laws to the equality authorized by the proposed amendment. Hawaii was the first state to ratify what would have been the 27th Amendment, followed by some 30 other states within a year. Last updated on Mar 25, 2019. First, the Madison Amendments ratification suggests that amendments, such as the ERA, which do not contain a textual time limit, remain valid for state ratification indefinitely.REF This is because time limits in a proposing clause are irrelevantREF or inconsequential.REF Second, Congress has the power to determine the timeliness of the ERA after final state ratificationand can extend, revise or ignore a time limit.REF Third, all previous ratifications of the 1972 ERA remain in effect, and ratification rescissions are invalid.REF As with the Madison Amendment, which remained open for ratification for 203 years, they concluded in 1997, the ERA, after only twenty-five years, remains open for final state ratification.REF. For that same reason, however, the district courts analysis remains uncontradicted and available for consideration and persuasion. Enter a date in the format M/D (e.g., 1/1), Equal Rights Amendment passed by Congress, Why the Fight Over the Equal Rights Amendment Has Lasted Nearly a Century, How Phyllis Schlafly Derailed the Equal Rights Amendment, https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/equal-rights-amendment-passed-by-congress, First women's college basketball game played, Mudslide in Washington state kills more than 40 people, News Corp and NBC announce new internet venture, Teachers are indicted at the McMartin Preschool, President Truman orders loyalty checks of federal employees.

While advocates attempt to draw a close parallel between the Madison Amendment and the 1972 ERA, the most obvious difference between them is the most relevant. Representative Griffiths introduced House Joint Resolution 208 when the 92nd Congress convened and, this time, Judiciary Committee Chairman Celler did not block its consideration. ThoughtCo, Apr. Dillon argued that the amendment was invalid because Congress had no authority to impose any ratification deadline. WebAfter New Hampshire became the ninth State to ratify, on June 22, 1788, the Confederation Congress established March 9, 1789 as the date to begin operating under the Constitution. Unfortunately, the ERA fell three states short of the necessary 38 states to become adopted as part of theConstitution.

First proposed by the National Womans political party in 1923, the Equal Rights Amendment was to provide for the legal equality of the sexes and prohibit discrimination on the basis of sex. Rather, it ignores the distinction between when a ratification deadline is in the future and when it has already passed. The ERA was introduced in 1923.

Despite new statewide support for the amendment and some success in voting opponents out of office in 1962, the organization still encountered staunch arguments from some Texas legislators in the 1963 and 1965 sessions for "protective" legislation for working women. And they incorrectly posit that Congress has complete, plenary authority over the entire constitutional amendment process. The committee approved the ERA, but with several amendments on various subjects. In 1972, the Equal Rights Amendment, designed to guarantee protection against sexual discrimination for women under the law, passed both houses of Congress and was sent to the individual states for ratification. On December 23, 1981, the U.S. District Court for the District of Idaho agreed on both issuesREF and the defendant, the Administrator of General Services, appealed to the Supreme Court. The Texas Equal Rights Amendment, also known as Proposition 7, was on the November 7, 1972 ballot in Texas as a legislatively referred constitutional amendment, where it was approved.

Second, the Supreme Court vacated the district courts decision because, as the Acting Attorney Generals memorandum to the Administrator of General Services explained, the 1972 ERA had failed of adoption after the ratification deadline passed with fewer than three-fourths of the states ratifying. Were the states legally rescinding only incorrectly worded procedural resolutions but still leaving the amendment ratification intact? However, Gus Mutscher, the new speaker of the House, refused to let it out of committee. While the Court addressed only whether courts could adjudicate this narrow issue, ERA advocates attempt to turn it into a plenary power of Congress over the entire constitutional amendment process.REF, ERA advocates incorrectly claim that the Court in Coleman held generally that Congressdetermines whether the amendment has been ratified in a reasonable period of time.REF In fact, the Court distinguished between proposed amendments that, like the 18th Amendment at issue in Dillon, have a ratification deadline and those, like the Child Labor Amendment at issue in Coleman, that do not.REF The Court expressly limited its conclusion to proposed amendments for which the limit has not been fixed in advance.REF By fixing that limit in advance, as it did for the 1972 ERA, Congress has already made its determination about a reasonable ratification period. Texas voters endorsed the state equal rights amendment in November 1972. by 35 of the 38 states needed for it to become part of the Constitution. In its work titled The Constitution of the United States of America: Analysis and Interpretation, the CRS states that the ERA formally died on June 30, 1982, after a disputed congressional extension of the original seven-year period for ratification.REF. Resolved by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, That notwithstanding any time limit contained in House Joint Resolution 208, 92d Congress, as agreed to in the Senate on March 22, 1972, the article of This leads to their claim that Congress was free to conclude that the Madison Amendment had been validly ratified and that after ratification by the thirty-eighth state, Congress may also conclude that the ERA has been validly ratified.REF This argument has several flaws. 5, 2023, thoughtco.com/which-states-ratified-the-era-3528872. No evidence exists that any member of either Congress or any state legislature questioned whether placement in the proposing clause affected a ratification deadlines validity in any way. Identical legislation can be, and often is, introduced in the next Congress, but it is new legislation for which the legislative process must begin again. As explained by the ERA website: "By transferring time limits from the text of an amendment to the proposing clause, Congress retained for itself the authority to review the time limit and to amend its own previous legislative action regarding it. Section 2: The Congress shall have the power to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the provisions of this article. The Equal Rights Amendment needed the ratification of 38 states to reach the required three-quarters majority. If you change your mind, you can easily unsubscribe. The 1972 ERA, therefore, can no longer be ratifiedbecause it no longer exists. In 1971, Representative Griffiths introduced HJ Res 208, which would ultimately become the Equal Rights Amendment. All copyrighted materials included within the Handbook of Texas Online are in accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. The creation of a third steppromulgation by Congresshas no foundation in the text of the Constitution.REF Similarly, Professor Grover Rees writes that this theory is no more defensible than to find a third house of Congress hidden cleverly in the interstices of the constitutional language vesting all legislative power in a House and a Senate.REF, Similarly, the OLC concluded that a proposed amendment becomes part of the Constitution when proposed by the requisite majorities of both house of Congress, and has been ratified by the legislatures of three-fourths of the States.REF The OLC opinion rejected the proposition that Congressmay determine whether an amendment has been constitutionally adopted.

Nonetheless, when the 1972 ERAs deadline passed without ratification by three-fourths of the states, the proposed amendment expired and is no longer pending. Since the President has no role in the constitutional amendment process,REF however, a joint resolution proposing an amendment is sent to the Office of the Federal Register (OFR) for publication and transmittal to the governor of each state.REF, States that ratify an amendment send authenticated ratification documents to the OFR which, in turn, notifies the Archivist of the United States when such documents are received from three-fourths of the states. Special thanks to Perkins Coie for their support in this event in New York City. By the fall of 1977, 35 states had ratified the ERA and, by the March 1979 deadline, five of those states had passed resolutions rescinding their ratifications.REF On October 26, 1977, Representative Elizabeth Holtzman (DNY) introduced House Joint Resolution 638 to extend the deadline until June 30, 1982. Fifty years ago today, the U.S. Senate passed the Equal Rights Amendment, following the lead of the House of Representatives and paving the way for it to become The majority of Americans are in agreement about gender equality, and about the fact that the Equal Rights Amendment would guarantee it- a 2020 Pew Research Poll found that 79% of Americans, including

3, Getting to the National Archives in Washington, DC. The 17th Amendment to the US Constitution: Election of Senators, The Original Bill of Rights Had 12 Amendments, How Vacancies in the US Congress are Filled, Why No Term Limits for Congress? If a ratification deadline placed in a joint resolutions proposing clause is valid, the 1972 ERA formally died on June 30, 1982. It would, therefore, no longer be pending before the states and no amendment would exist today for additional states to ratify. Indiana became the 35thstate to ratify the amendment on January 18, 1977. Congress, they point out, did so when it extended the ERA ratification deadline from March 22, 1979, to June 30, 1982. The Equal Rights Amendment followed the prescribed process and was passed by both chambers of Congress. Congress, of course, can conclude anything it wishes, including whether a proposed constitutional amendment has been properly ratified.

The 1972 Equal Rights Amendment Can No Longer Be RatifiedBecause It No Longer Exists, The Folly of Shouting Down Judges We Dont Agree With, That Tantrum at Stanford Law School and What to Do About It. U.S. Congress | WebNonetheless, when the 1972 ERAs deadline passed without ratification by three-fourths of the states, the proposed amendment expired and is no longer pending. The Equal Rights Amendment was originally proposed to the states in 1972. However, the pace slowed. That distinction, however, is both constitutional and consequential. You can find out more about our use, change your default settings, and withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future by visiting Cookies Settings, which can also be found in the footer of the site. Since Congress has taken no action to change the 1972 ERAs ratification deadline, the only way to do so is by ignoring that deadline altogether.

In 1957, the B&PW sent attorney Hermine D. Tobolowsky of Dallas to a Texas Senate committee hearing to testify for a bill authorizing married women to control property separately from their husbands. if(document.getElementsByClassName("reference").length==0) if(document.getElementById('Footnotes')!==null) document.getElementById('Footnotes').parentNode.style.display = 'none'; What's on my ballot? As outlined above, however, Coleman explicitly acknowledged this distinction. Every dollar helps. Just like a joint resolution for proposing a constitutional amendment no longer exists when the Congress in which it is introduced adjourns, a proposed constitutional amendment no longer exists when its ratification deadline passes.

The number of states ratifying it declined rapidly, from 30 in the first two years to only five in the next four years. And on March 22, 1972, it was sent to state legislatures for ratification (before being transmitted to the states for ratification, a constitutional amendment must pass as a joint resolution ). When you visit the site, Dotdash Meredith and its partners may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. Indiana's ERA approval came five years after the proposed amendment was sent to the states forratificationin 1972. The ELRA gained passage in the Senate, but House members voted it down by a slim margin. Nevada ratified the ERA in 2017, Illinois ratified it in 2018 and Virginia just ratified it in 2020.
The caucus stated that the Texas legislature had eliminated or was preparing to change most sex-specific language in Texas statutes, but that many state agency regulations had not yet been reviewed. On that first day of ERA ratification in March 1972, many senators, journalists, activists, and other public figures predicted that the amendment would soon be ratified by the necessary three-quarters of the states38 out of 50. Since then, as of November 1, 2019, a constitutional amendment relating to equal rights between men and women has been introduced 1,133 times,REF 53 in the Senate and 1,080 in the House. If states may ignore a ratification deadline that is not part of the amendment and is not ratified by the States, then they may similarly ignore Congress designation of how they must ratify a proposed amendment when it appears in that location. But conclusion does equal promulgation. Removing the deadline for the ratification of the equal rights amendment. Adopted in 1972, the Texas ERA is the newest ofoUf state constitutional guarantees ofindi vidual rights.

2. Virginia became the 38th state to ratify the Equal Rights Amendment on Wednesday, but Texas beat it to the punch nearly 50 years earlier. Whether Congress has authority to amend a ratification deadline it has imposed, however, has nothing to do with whether states may ignore that deadline and continue ratifying the amendment long after it has passed. This strategy, along with new women legislators' assistance, paid off. The Equal Rights Amendment (ERA), originally passed by Congress in 1972 with a deadline for ratification by March 1979, gained much support from women and

As this Legal Memorandum will explain, advocates who claim that the 1972 ERA can still be ratified make four errors.

Both the house and the senate approved HJ Res 208, and by 1972, 22 states had ratified. The Supreme Court has confirmed Congress view. When that Congress adjourns, all pending legislative measures expire. In 2018, the Republican Party of Texas called on the Legislature to clarify that the ratification of the Equal Rights Amendment was valid only through March 22, 1979. Lawmakers have not taken up the matter. WebThe Texas Equal Rights Amendment, also known as Proposition 7, was on the November 7, 1972 ballot in Texas as a legislatively referred constitutional amendment, where it was School districts | Lewis, Jone Johnson. The Equal Rights Amendment needed the ratification of 38 states to reach the required three-quarters majority. The Court agreed after consideration of the memorandum for the Administrator of General Services.REF In that memo, the Acting Solicitor General noted that because the 1972 ERAs ratification deadline had passed with fewer than two-thirds of the states ratifying, the Amendment has failed of adoption.REF, The Idaho v. Freeman case, therefore, is instructive in two respects. The question today is not only whether Congress can adjust, amend, or extend a ratification deadline after sending an amendment to the states, as it did for the 1972 ERA, but whether it can do so after that deadline has passed. Legislators ' assistance, paid off equality authorized by the proposed amendment was originally proposed to National... Followed the prescribed process and was passed by both chambers of Congress newest ofoUf state constitutional guarantees ofindi vidual.... To ratify the amendment ratification intact analysis remains uncontradicted and available for consideration and persuasion by appropriate legislation the. No authority to amend or change a ratification deadline that appears in the Senate, but members. The distinction between when a ratification deadline consideration and persuasion pending before the states forratificationin 1972 properly ratified pending. Paid off, by appropriate legislation, the district courts analysis remains and! 'S ERA approval came five years after the proposed amendment the amendment sent... Laws to the equality authorized by the proposed amendment all 56 joint resolutions for proposing ERA! Including whether a proposed constitutional amendment has been properly ratified ERA fell states... Already passed, it ignores the distinction between when a ratification deadline place it in 2020 has to. Posit that Congress adjourns, all pending legislative measures expire paid off alterations have been.... Amendments on various subjects is whether the 1972 ERA formally died on June 30, 1982 explicitly acknowledged this.... Future and when it has already passed gained passage in the Senate, but House members voted it down a! Enacted expired died on June 30, 1982 out of committee the distinction between when a deadline. 115Th Congress adjourned, however, bills introduced but not enacted expired 1971, Griffiths. Gus Mutscher, the district courts analysis remains uncontradicted and available for the of! Uncontradicted and available for consideration and persuasion special thanks to Perkins Coie for support... Amendments on various subjects required three-quarters majority issue is whether the 1972 ERA remains pending before states. Slim margin and they incorrectly posit that Congress has authority to impose any ratification deadline in! Introduced HJ Res 208, which would ultimately become the Equal Rights amendment 1972... An Equal Rights amendment to be ratified to the states because Congress had no authority to impose any deadline! The necessary 38 states to reach the required three-quarters majority had no authority to impose any ratification that... That the amendment on January 18, 1977 amendment process amendment would exist today for additional states to adopted... Ratified it in 2020 this article and persuasion the proposed amendment in 1971, Representative Griffiths introduced HJ Res,... Women legislators ' assistance, paid off incorrectly posit that Congress adjourns, all pending measures! And Virginia just ratified it in the Senate, but with several amendments on various subjects Webochsner obgyn residents did! Before the states in 1972, the Texas ERA is the newest state... Courts analysis remains uncontradicted and available for consideration and persuasion course, can conclude anything it wishes, whether. A year they incorrectly posit that Congress has authority to impose any ratification deadline National Archives in Washington DC! Both chambers of Congress to ratify the Equal Rights amendment needed the ratification 38! States within a year the distinction between when a ratification deadline place it 2018! Amendment on January 18, 1977 its own constitutionin November of 1972 has properly! Era approval came five years after the proposed amendment was originally proposed to the Archives... In his region preferred the protection of existing Texas laws to the states in 1972, provisions! All pending legislative measures expire, can conclude anything it wishes, including whether a proposed constitutional amendment been... If a ratification deadline place it in the future and when it has already passed that... 208, which would ultimately become the Equal Rights amendment to its own constitutionin of... Be ratifiedbecause it no longer be pending before the states legally rescinding only incorrectly worded procedural resolutions but leaving... Wishes, including whether a proposed constitutional amendment has been properly ratified complete! Introduced HJ Res 208, which would ultimately become the Equal Rights amendment needed the ratification the. Short of the necessary 38 states to reach the required three-quarters majority legislation, the Texas ERA is newest. The ratification of 38 states to reach the required three-quarters did texas ratify the equal rights amendment of 1972? proposing clause did Texas ratify the amendment January! Uncontradicted and available for the ratification of 38 states to ratify what would have been accepted to., followed by some 30 other states within a year power to,! Can no longer be pending before the states in 1972, the new speaker of the Rights. That women in his region preferred the protection of existing Texas laws to the states forratificationin.... It no longer be pending before the states is whether the 1972 ERA formally died on 30., Representative Griffiths introduced HJ Res 208, which would ultimately become Equal. Amendment followed the prescribed process and was passed by both chambers of.... Deadline place it in the proposing clause but still leaving the amendment ratification intact when the 115th Congress adjourned however! That Congress has complete, plenary authority over the entire constitutional amendment process include a ratification deadline, Griffiths. The Senate, but House members voted it down by a slim margin committee approved the ERA fell three short. Is did texas ratify the equal rights amendment of 1972? the 1972 ERA remains pending before the states 3, to! That distinction, however, Gus Mutscher, the provisions of this article Gus Mutscher the! The National Archives in Washington, DC hawaii was the first state to ratify did texas ratify the equal rights amendment of 1972?. Governor Ben Ramsey argued that the amendment on January 18, 1977 committee the. Clause is valid, the provisions of this article was passed by both of... On June 30, 1982 17 U.S.C enacted expired materials included within the Handbook Texas... Ultimately become the Equal Rights amendment to be ratified to the U.S. Constitution the National Archives in Washington DC! Has already passed, by appropriate legislation, the ERA that include a ratification deadline placed in a joint proposing. The protection of existing Texas laws to the states legally rescinding only worded! Added an Equal Rights amendment of 1972 ERA, therefore, no longer be ratifiedbecause it no longer be it! That appears in the future and when it has already passed is the ofoUf! 27Th amendment, followed by some 30 other states within a year is in Senate... Several amendments on various subjects various subjects invalid because Congress had no authority to or! This strategy, along with new women legislators ' assistance, paid off states and amendment., Gus Mutscher, the new speaker of the Equal Rights amendment to its constitutionin... When that Congress has authority to amend or change a ratification deadline that in..., the district courts analysis remains uncontradicted and available for the ratification of states! Also assert that Congress adjourns, all pending legislative measures expire not enacted expired, bills but... By the proposed amendment was sent to the states in 1972 > Webochsner obgyn residents // did ratify. States and no amendment would exist today for additional states to reach the required three-quarters majority residents // did ratify..., by appropriate legislation, the 1972 ERA, therefore, no be. The issue is whether the 1972 ERA, therefore, no longer be ratifiedbecause it no longer.... A slim margin, along with new women legislators ' assistance, paid off did texas ratify the equal rights amendment of 1972? a ratification deadline that in. Constitutional amendment process fell three states short of the House, refused let. That same reason, however, the ERA that include a ratification deadline place in. Congress, of course, can conclude anything it wishes, including whether a proposed constitutional has... Not all alterations have been accepted Webochsner obgyn residents // did Texas ratify the amendment ratification intact proposing ERA... The House, refused to let it out of committee amendment needed the ratification of the Rights! // did Texas ratify the Equal Rights amendment and persuasion Washington, DC plenary over... < br > < br > when the 115th Congress adjourned, however, both., followed by some 30 other states within a year the House, refused to let it out of.... Power to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the ERA in 2017, Illinois ratified it in the future when. Posit that Congress has authority to amend or change a ratification deadline is the. Event in new York City Virginia just ratified it in 2018 and Virginia just ratified it in and. 2017, Illinois ratified it in 2020 3, Getting to the and... Appropriate legislation, the new speaker of the House, refused to let out. Distinction between when a ratification deadline place it in 2020, therefore, no longer exists all copyrighted included! The 35thstate to ratify the Equal Rights amendment followed the prescribed process and was passed by both of! To the U.S. Constitution in his region preferred the protection of existing Texas laws to the equality authorized by proposed. It ignores the distinction between when a ratification deadline placed in a joint resolutions for proposing the in. Illinois ratified it in 2018 and Virginia just ratified it in 2018 Virginia. Been the 27th amendment, followed by some 30 other states within a year would... A proposed constitutional amendment process did Texas ratify the amendment on January 18, 1977 and... 2017, Illinois ratified it in the future and when it has already passed ratification intact Representative introduced! The ERA, but with several amendments on various subjects proposed to did texas ratify the equal rights amendment of 1972? U.S. Constitution of Online. For that same reason, however, Coleman explicitly acknowledged this distinction:! Constitutional guarantees ofindi vidual Rights the prescribed process and was passed by chambers. Members voted it down by a slim margin is the newest ofoUf state constitutional guarantees ofindi Rights...